Depending on its active ingredient, a drugstore lice shampoo may not kill lice eggs, and in some communities it may not kill lice that have become resistant to it. The CDC’s clinical guidance on head lice says pyrethrins and permethrin kill live lice but not unhatched eggs, and the AAP’s review of lice treatment myths says lice can resist the active ingredients in over-the-counter treatments in some communities. Your answer starts on the label: find the active ingredient, then check what it can and cannot do.

Knowing that matters before you buy another bottle. Some lice medicines call for a second treatment by design, some can be undercut by something as ordinary as conditioner, and some aren’t approved for every age in the house. Below, we match each active ingredient to what it does, explain why live lice can survive, and lay out what the CDC and AAP say about using these products across a family.

What Is the Active Ingredient in Lice Shampoo, and What Does It Kill?

The active ingredient printed on the box tells you whether a lice product is meant to kill live lice only or eggs as well. The CDC notes that each over-the-counter head lice product approved by the FDA contains one of a specific set of active ingredients, and that both over-the-counter and prescription medicines are available to treat head lice effectively. It calls these medicines pediculicides, a word that simply means lice killers.

Here is what the CDC says about four active ingredients used in lice medicines, over the counter or by prescription. Find the one on your label, then read across the row.

Active ingredientWhat the CDC says about lice and eggsAges the CDC lists
Pyrethrins combined with piperonyl butoxideKills live lice only, not unhatched eggs (nits)2 years and older
Permethrin lotion, 1%Kills live lice but not unhatched eggs; can kill newly hatched lice for several days after treatment2 months and older
Malathion lotion, 0.5%Kills live lice and some lice eggs (partially ovicidal)6 years and older
Spinosad 0.9% topical suspensionNits do not need to be removed when treating with it6 months and older

The CDC describes two more: benzyl alcohol lotion, 5%, intended for people six months of age and older, and ivermectin lotion, 0.5%, approved for people six months of age and older. Whether a particular ingredient sits on the open shelf or needs a prescription is something the box or your pharmacist can confirm. Whatever the product, the CDC’s advice on treating head lice starts with the label: use the lice medicine as directed on the box or label.

Why Lice Eggs Can Outlast the First Treatment

Eggs can outlast a first treatment because some lice medicines kill only lice that have already hatched. The CDC draws the line clearly: some medicines kill lice and eggs, while others kill lice but are not effective at killing eggs, and retreatment is recommended for those. In the table above, pyrethrins and permethrin fall in the second group, and malathion kills some eggs.

Timing is the whole point of that second round. According to the CDC, nits take about a week to hatch, with a range of six to nine days, and newly hatched lice need about seven more days to mature into adults. The CDC’s aim is to treat again after all eggs have hatched but before new eggs are produced. For a medicine that kills lice but not eggs, it puts that at about a week after the first treatment, or 7 to 9 days depending on the drug. Your product label and your child’s doctor set the exact day.

Leftover nits on their own don’t prove the treatment failed, and they don’t prove it worked either. The CDC notes that nits may stay in hair after treatment, but successful treatment will kill crawling lice, and the AAP explains that empty nits stay on the hair shaft after the eggs hatch. Our guide on how to identify lice eggs (nits) in hair shows what a nit looks like up close, and if a check turns up nits but no crawling lice, here is why nits but no bugs doesn’t mean you’re in the clear.

Combing works alongside medicine. The CDC recommends nit combs to remove nits and lice from the hair shaft and notes that flea combs made for cats and dogs are also effective. The AAP is realistic about combing’s limits, noting that “the comb-out method usually doesn’t work on its own to get rid of head lice.”

Lice That Won’t Die: Why a Treatment Can Fail

When live lice turn up after treatment, resistance is only one of five reasons the CDC gives for a treatment failing. It’s worth ruling out the other four before buying anything new:

  • Misdiagnosis. The CDC calls misdiagnosis of head lice common and notes that nits can be confused with dandruff, hair spray droplets and dirt particles. If the bugs you spotted were on books or shelves rather than in hair, read why booklice call for a head check before you treat hair.
  • A recent conditioner. The CDC lists recent use of conditioner or a combination shampoo/conditioner among the causes, and says not to use either before lice medicine. Here is why lice shampoo and conditioner do two different jobs.
  • Instructions not followed. The AAP calls it essential for parents to read and follow manufacturer instructions exactly as written.
  • Resistance. The CDC says lice have developed some resistance to 1% permethrin, though the prevalence of that resistance is unknown, and that resistance may reduce the efficacy of pyrethrins. The AAP adds that the likelihood of resistance varies across the country.
  • Reinfestation. A treatment can succeed and lice can still return from someone who has them. The CDC says head lice mainly spread by direct contact with the hair of a person infested with lice.

How do you tell when the medicine itself isn’t working? The CDC says that if you don’t find any dead lice, or the lice seem as active as before treatment, the medicine may not be working. Its advice then is to talk to your healthcare provider before re-treating, since they may suggest a different medicine. The CDC also says not to treat a person more than two or three times with the same medication if it isn’t successful, and to consider an alternative medication if crawling lice are still present after a full course of treatment and retreatment.

If you’ve already been through several rounds, the AAP notes that parents sometimes treat their children with over-the-counter products up to five times before seeking help from their pediatrician, and it recommends checking with your child’s doctor before beginning a second or third medicine.

What Lice Shampoo Can You Use on the Whole Family?

There isn’t one lice shampoo meant for every person in the house, because not everyone may need treatment. The CDC’s advice is to check all household members and other close contacts, then treat every infested person, along with the people they share a bed with, at the same time. The AAP adds that head lice medicine should be used only when it is certain your child has living head lice.

Age is the next filter. The minimum ages in the table run from two months to six years depending on the ingredient, so a product that suits a parent or an older child may not be approved for a toddler. The CDC says to consult your healthcare provider before treating young children, and MedlinePlus, from the NIH, also says to check with your health care provider first if you want to use a treatment on a young child. Hair length counts too: the CDC notes that shoulder-length hair or longer might need a second bottle.

A careful check is what makes the family plan work. The CDC says finding a live nymph or adult louse on the scalp or hair is the best way to diagnose head lice. The AAP describes a comb-out check: wet the hair, comb through it in small sections with a fine-tooth louse or nit comb, and wipe the comb on a wet paper towel after each pass, then examine the scalp, comb and towel. If no live lice turn up and the only nits are more than a quarter inch from the scalp, the CDC says the infestation is probably old and does not need treatment.

Does Lice Shampoo Damage Hair or Irritate the Scalp?

The side effects the CDC describes are on the skin and eyes: some lice medications may cause itching or a mild burning sensation, and malathion can irritate skin. The CDC’s sharper warning is about how the products are used. It reminds families that the drugs used to treat lice are insecticides that can be dangerous if misused or overused, and it says not to use extra amounts of any lice medication unless your physician and pharmacist tell you to.

A few more cautions from the CDC and AAP:

  • Keep all lice medicines out of the eyes, and flush the eyes right away if any gets in, as the CDC advises.
  • The AAP says medicine should be applied by an adult. Never let children apply it, and never leave a child alone with medicine in their hair.
  • To rinse, the AAP describes placing the child’s head over a sink and using warm water, not hot water.
  • Malathion is flammable, and the CDC names hair dryers, curlers, and curling or flat irons among the electrical heat sources not to use, along with smoking.

That heat warning is about a flammable lotion. If you’ve wondered whether heat on its own does anything to lice, we cover whether a hair dryer kills head lice in a separate post.

One thing that can feel like a reaction but may not be: the AAP notes that itching caused by head lice can last for weeks, even after the lice are gone. A lingering itch alone doesn’t show that a product failed, which is why a check for live lice comes before any decision about another round.

Is There a Best Lice Shampoo? What the AAP Suggests Instead

No single lice shampoo is the right pick for every child, and the AAP says it is best to call your pediatrician before treatment, because your pediatrician can help you choose an appropriate option for your child. The AAP also says over-the-counter head lice treatments sometimes are not the most effective, and that local resistance patterns can shape which treatment is used first in some communities. It still names head lice medicine as the most effective way to treat head lice, which is why the choice deserves that conversation.

Prescription options give the doctor more to work with. According to the AAP, several prescription treatments are safe to use on children as young as six months of age, several suggest using only one application, some have application times as short as 10 minutes followed by a simple rinse with water, and some don’t call for nit combing.

Some remedies don’t belong on the list at all. The CDC says it does not have scientific evidence that suffocating head lice with mayonnaise, olive oil, margarine, butter or similar substances is an effective treatment, and the AAP says not to use home remedies such as petroleum jelly, essential oils or olive oil, because no studies prove they work. If coconut oil is the remedy you’ve heard about, see whether coconut oil actually kills head lice and nits.

The AAP also sets firm limits: never use dangerous products like gasoline or kerosene or medicines made for use on animals, and never place a plastic bag on a child’s head.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does lice shampoo kill nits?

Only some lice medicines kill eggs, and the active ingredient decides which. Neither pyrethrins nor permethrin kills unhatched eggs, according to the CDC, while some other medicines kill both lice and eggs. When a medicine leaves eggs alive, the CDC recommends treating a second time once the eggs have hatched and before new ones are laid, on the schedule your label gives.

Can you buy lice shampoo over the counter?

Yes. The CDC says head lice can be treated with medicines that are either over-the-counter or by prescription. MedlinePlus, from the NIH, says that if an over-the-counter treatment does not work for you, you can ask your health care provider for a prescription product. The AAP still suggests calling your pediatrician before any treatment, including one picked up at a store, so the choice fits your child.

What does a pediculicide kill?

A pediculicide kills lice; the CDC uses the word for head lice medicines sold over the counter or by prescription. Killing lice and killing eggs are separate jobs, though. The CDC describes malathion as pediculicidal, which means it kills live lice, and partially ovicidal, which means it kills some eggs, so what any pediculicide does to nits depends on its ingredient.

Why are some lice still moving hours after treatment?

Lice can take a while to die, so slow movement soon after treatment isn’t automatically a sign of failure. The CDC says it takes time to kill all the lice, and that if a few are still moving slowly 8 to 12 hours after treatment, you do not need to reapply the medicine. It advises treating again only if live, crawling lice are present several days later, after talking with your healthcare provider.

Can two lice products be used at the same time?

Not unless a doctor or pharmacist tells you to. The CDC says not to use different head lice drugs at the same time unless your healthcare provider or pharmacist instructs you to, and MedlinePlus advises using only one product at a time unless your health care provider tells you to use two different kinds at once. If one product hasn’t worked, ask your child’s doctor what to try next.

How long should you wait to wash hair after lice medicine?

The CDC says not to re-wash the hair for one to two days after removing the lice medicine. The AAP gives a matching window, advising no shampoo for 24 to 48 hours afterward. Your product’s own directions may add details, and the AAP’s guidance is to follow the directions on the package exactly as written, so read the label before that first wash.

How Lice Lifters of Broward County Can Help

If reading labels and counting days to a second round isn’t how you want to spend this week, our clinic can help. Lice Lifters of Broward County checks the whole family, which fits the CDC’s advice to check everyone in the household. Our non-toxic treatment is completed in one visit, and we offer same-day appointments. When the whole family is checked, our 30 Day Guarantee applies. For egg, nit and shampoo concerns, reliable options are professional Lice Lifters treatment and Lice Lifters products. You can read more about our professional lice treatment, or book a head check whenever you’re ready. Questions about a specific medicine remain a conversation for your child’s doctor.